Whiskey Cookies

March 23, 2011

Whiskey Cookies

You might remember the butter from its previous engagement in my armpits.

As someone has most likely said, “you know what’s missing in most baked goods? Alcohol.”

Thus Whiskey Cookies ride to the rescue.

Whiskey Cookies

Feel free to blame the yellow-ness on the butter and not my photography.

Skye had practiced making them for a work event in my kitchen and I have fond memories of the results.

Yet, that baking session took place over a year ago, so when I emailed Skye to request the recipe, she had no idea what I was talking about.

I ended up with an email of three separate whiskey cookie recipes, and Skye’s suggestion that she’d probably mixed the first two, though wasn’t sure which ingredients of which she’d used.

I’d already dedicated myself to whiskey baking, so keeping fond past cookies in my mind, I pressed forward, choosing to use the ingredients I had lying about my kitchen.

Whiskey Cookies

The foundation of any great recipe.

After all, I already knew the most important step.

(That step was adding whiskey.)

Whiskey Cookies

If gnomes don't exist, then who's stealing my toilet paper, huh?

I was going to add 8 tbs of whiskey to the batter.

Strangely, the only measuring spoon I could find was ½ tbs.

(Exhibit D in the case of Megan’s Kitchen v. Gnomes.)

Putting in ½ tbs after ½ tbs made me start feeling excessive, and with thoughts of my coworkers taking a bite and looking at me askew, I stopped at 6 tbs.

Whiskey Cookies

Beware of flying flour.

After realizing I was all out of flour, then realizing I can’t tell the difference between flour and sugar, then realizing I should probably not be left alone near heat sources, I added the 2 cups flour.

Then realized I should have worn an apron.

(No above use of realization should be confused with self-realization.)

(Mainly because I’m not sure I understand the latter.)

Whiskey Cookies

On second thought, I blame the color on the bowl. Stupid lime green dishware.

It was at this step that I realized these were the wrong cookies.

Skye’s cookies were brown.

These cookies were clearly not destined to turn brown.

At least not unless there was a severe oven malfunction.

Which shouldn’t be discounted as a possibility.

Whiskey Cookies

Speaking of yellowing... don't fear - the pan isn't dirty, it's just old and rusty.

Take close notice of the random spread of cookies.

Whiskey Cookies

Speaking of dirty things... meet my oven, Mr. Stove. (He's contrary.)

Don’t do that.

Whiskey Cookies

Everything looks delicious on a cake plate. Except peas.

They weren’t half bad.

Though it turns out they could have used just a tad more whiskey.

Or a lot more whiskey.

Probably the second.

Megan’s Whiskey Cookie Recipe

-recreated to the best of her ability-

1 cup (2 sticks) butter (salt optional) (maybe) (I never remember to pay attention to that)

3 eggs

1 cup white sugar (I totally neglected to tell you about the sugar) (Surprise!)

2 cups flour

8 tbs whiskey (or more, really) (yeah, definitely add quite a bit more)

 

Pre-Step. Preheat oven to 350°. (This wasn’t included in Skye’s instructions and was thus made up by me.)

Step 1. Mix eggs, butter and sugar together. (This will go faster if butter is softened with body heat.)

Step 2. Add whiskey.

Step 2B. Add more whiskey. (Then add a bit more.)

Step 3. Put on apron.

Step 4. Add flour.

Step 5. Form dough into balls and place on cookie sheet. Try and put them far, far apart.

Step 6. Bake cookies in the oven for 10 minutes.

Step 7. Look at cookies. Do they look uncooked? Put them back in for another little while.

Step 8. Eventually decide the edges of the cookies are too brown and you should have taken them out a few minutes earlier.

Step 9. Consume.

Just wait ’til I share the Bailey’s cupcakes

They’ll blow your mind,

Megan

Whiskey Cookies

{ 36 comments… read them below or add one }

Jackie March 23, 2011

Yum! I love your posts and adventures. Did you know that when you cook with alcoholic drinks, the alcohol evapor–!

Immediate addendum – The jubilation caused by your post caused me to knock over and spill my Cosmo. Arg! If you haven’t had a cosmo before, give it a shot! You will likely find them delicious.
Guestimation recipe:
1 oz Vodka
1/2 oz Triple Sec (Orange Liqueur)
1/4 oz Lime Juice (or half a lime juiced ((the tastiest)))
3ish oz Cranberry Juice

I usually just pour bits of the ingredients in at random until tasty.

Reply

Megan March 23, 2011

That sounds delicious.

And may I add – I highly approve of drinking while reading my posts.

Reply

blackhuff March 23, 2011

I like any food with alcohol in them especially Brandy
These look yummy :)

Reply

Alaina March 23, 2011

You had me at whiskey :-)

Reply

Lance March 23, 2011

Alaina stole my answer.

I bet those ccokies smell awesome. After about 7 of them, I’ll tell you whatever you want to know.

Reply

Megan March 23, 2011

Hmm, now that I know my torture methods I just need to compose some questions!

Reply

Jen March 23, 2011

I am a little scared of the arm pit butter but the cookies look good.

Reply

Stephanie @ Our Marriage Adventure March 23, 2011

These deserve to be made (and eaten) if for no other reason than Whiskey. I mean come on….that’s like Rum Pancakes. You make ‘em because of the name!

Reply

Megan March 23, 2011

You must share these “rum pancakes” – they sound delicious!

Reply

Katie March 23, 2011

My SIL makes American Honey cupcakes from Annie’s Eats! Oh my goodness, they are so yummy! I’m all about more alcohol in my baking.

Reply

liz March 23, 2011

I had no idea such a culinary delight existed!

Reply

Pop March 23, 2011

Great minds must think alike. I was making Bacon BBQ beans this past weekend and thought, “You know what this needs? Bourbon.” So I put in a little bourbon. Then I put in a little more. Then a lot. Just goes to show that no one knows how to party like Jim Beam or his friend Jack Daniel.

Also, your recipe has a fatal flaw/omission:

Step 2c. drink whiskey
Step 2d. drink more whiskey
step 2e. pass out on the couch for a bit and make your friends finish baking

Reply

Megan March 23, 2011

Hmm… I am a huge fan of taking advantage of my friends…

Reply

Pop March 23, 2011

If I misconstrue what you just wrote (which I like to do) remind me never to pass out on your couch lest I get taken advantage of.

Reply

Megan March 23, 2011

My living room is a dangerous, dangerous place.

Reply

Skye March 23, 2011

I’m so sad that I didn’t take notes on which recipe(s) I used! But I thought you said these were too flat and tasted bland… why are you subjecting your readers to them? (Dear other readers: I take blame only for the loss of original recipe, and not for how these cookies might turn out, as I was unable to taste test them.)

Reply

Megan March 23, 2011

Truthfully – yes, I did not like the cookies. Though that’s mainly because I think I used far too little whiskey, so if you added a lot more I think they’d be far better. And my coworkers ate every one and said they were good, so I’m sharing them with the hope that others agree with them and not me.

Reply

Nerdyredneck Rob March 23, 2011

Maybe it matters who’s armpits the butter is warmed in? ;)

Reply

Nerdyredneck Rob March 23, 2011

I’ll send you a bottle of Makers Mark so the next time even 6 spoons will be enough! :)

Reply

SpilledInkGuy March 23, 2011

They could always be dipped into more whiskey … Oreo-n-Milk style. Only different. OR ground up and mixed into more whiskey…
OR…
:)

Reply

Nerdyredneck Rob March 24, 2011

“OR ground up and mixed into more whiskey…”

OOOOooooOOooo – I LOVE that idea! Kinda like a whiskey slushy. Which just gave me the great idea of a Whiskey float; with Cookies n cream ice cream *of course*!

Reply

Bodaciousboomer March 23, 2011

Should I even ask about butter and your armpits? Honestly, it sounds scary.

Reply

Mindee@ourfrontdoor March 23, 2011

I think it might be easier to just drink the whiskey whilst eating a store bought cookie.

Reply

Stay At Home Babe March 23, 2011

I don’t know if anyone else said this, cuz I am WAY too lazy to read all the other comments, but lil tip. If you “cream” together (that’s like a technical term for the process and shit) the sugar and butter (when butter is at ROOM TEMPERATURE, not armpit temperature) before you add the egg, you’ll get that perfectly textured cookie that you will die for. Promise. leave the butter out for like an hour, then whip it together with the sugar until the sugar almost dissolves and it creams together and then add the egg. Thank me later!

Reply

gigi March 23, 2011

Drunk baking? I must try this. And drunk cookies.

I love you, Megan!

Reply

Galit Breen March 23, 2011

Serious YUM factor here! And OMG your narration- priceless!!

Reply

Malach March 23, 2011

MAIL ME SOME

Reply

Amanda March 23, 2011

Soooo…..do jello shots count as baking?

If so, I also bake with booze.

Reply

Krystyn March 24, 2011

Yeah…put in a lot more….go for it.

Everything’s better with booze, right? Well, maybe except like going to the doctor’s office.

Reply

Meg at the Members Lounge March 24, 2011

OK, pony up the Bailey’s cupcake recipe! I seriously love putting booze into food groups of all types…. :)

Reply

Melanie March 24, 2011

Ok, I’ve been mulling over your technique for softening butter. And I have arrived at a great new word for you. Warmpits!! Please feel free to use this noun in the future to describe the place you put the butter to soften it. YOU ARE WELCOME!

Reply

alonewithcats March 24, 2011

I wouldn’t mind getting booze cookies in the mail. Like, I wouldn’t object or anything. Because I’m very accepting of other people’s unprompted generosity.

Reply

mumma boo March 26, 2011

Whiskey cookies are fine for dessert, but make sure you have a proper breakfast. Like scrambled eggs made with Jack Daniels. Sometimes you have to improvise when you’re camping. ;-)

PS – I love reading your blog – you bring a smile with every post. Thank you for that!

Reply

Booyah's Momma March 26, 2011

In theory, I love this idea. But doesn’t the alcohol bake off when you put the cookies in the oven? In which case, could I just dip sugar cookies in whisky and call it a day?

Reply

Ironic Mother March 27, 2011

Megan, you write perfect recipes for me to follow. Let me know if you ever write a book on baby food recipes — I could have used your kitchen expertise as I tried to figure out when was the appropriate time during baby-food making to consume wine. http://ironicmother.blogspot.com/2010/08/wait-when-can-i-open-that-wine.html

Reply

JenMarie February 29, 2012

Wow. I’m totally intrigued with these.
Whiskey + Cookies = Love

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: